In the thriving culinary scene of Greenville, South Carolina, Carmella’s Dessert Bar has established itself as a beloved destination for those with a sweet tooth and an appreciation for quality dining experiences. What began as a Charleston favorite has now successfully expanded to Greenville, bringing its signature blend of decadent desserts, creative cocktails, and inviting atmosphere to a new audience eager to enjoy its offerings. Customer reviews consistently highlight the establishment’s ability to create memorable experiences that keep locals returning and visitors making it a must-stop on their itineraries.
A Sweet Expansion: Carmella’s Comes to Greenville
The dessert bar’s success stems from its dedication to quality and variety, offering everything from alcoholic milkshakes and dessert cocktails to gelato, cookies, cakes, and pies. Patrons often mention how they notice the consistently packed venue, drawing them in to discover what makes Carmella’s so special. As one Mt. Pleasant visitor enthusiastically stated, “Carmella’s is likely my favorite place in Charleston! I am in love with the whole vibe… when I go home, I talk about going to Charleston so I can visit Carmella’s.” This sentiment echoes throughout numerous reviews, where customers express making special trips just to experience what Carmella’s has to offer.
The Cannoli Cake Reigns Supreme
When it comes to favorite menu items at Carmella’s, the cannoli cake emerges as a clear frontrunner in customer reviews. One delighted patron from Greenville exclaimed, “Just went yesterday with my daughters and had a great experience! Sandwiches, pizza, gelato, and cannoli cake. Loved it all! Just go!!” Another visitor from Charleston shared similar enthusiasm: “Tried the cannoli cake and strawberry cookie, both were incredible! 10/10 would go again and recommend to others.” The establishment seems to particularly resonate with those familiar with authentic Italian desserts, as one reviewer noted, “We’re Italians from the Northeast and haven’t enjoyed such quality pastries in many years.”
Sips That Impress: Fan-Favorite Cocktails and Savories
Beyond the cannoli cake, customers rave about the carrot cake, chocolate peanut butter cake, and coconut raspberry cake—the latter described as “the best Thanksgiving dessert on the table” by one grateful customer. The drink menu receives equal praise, with the espresso martini and watermelon margarita frequently mentioned as standouts. One Madison Taylor from Charleston shared, “Delicious cocktails. Pictured are the watermelon margarita and the espresso martini.” While desserts might be the main attraction, savory options don’t take a backseat. The turkey and fig jam sandwich on ciabatta has earned particularly enthusiastic reviews, with one customer declaring it “to die for” and potentially “the best sandwich” they’ve ever had.
Ambiance That Elevates Every Visit
The atmosphere at Carmella’s consistently emerges as a key factor in the establishment’s appeal across both locations. Reviews frequently mention the environment of the space as something special that enhances the dining experience. The dessert bar seems to have mastered creating an environment that feels both occasion-worthy yet comfortable enough for regular visits. Customers describe it as “stunning,” with an ambiance that invites them to either linger and enjoy their treats on-site or take them to go for a waterfront stroll in Charleston.
Service That Shines: A Key Ingredient in Carmella’s Success
Service quality matches the high standards set by the food and atmosphere, with numerous reviewers specifically naming their servers and praising their knowledge and recommendations. As one Greenville visitor noted, “We stumbled upon Carmella’s after adventuring around the city all day! This place was unreal, the desserts were amazing, and our server, Molly, was the absolute best. She had great recommendations for us.” This attention to customer experience explains why Carmella’s has become more than just a dessert spot—it’s a destination that patrons plan their visits around. Multiple reviews mention making Carmella’s a daily stop during their time in Charleston or Greenville, with one enthusiast lamenting Google’s five-star limit, declaring that Carmella’s deserves “100 stars” for their exceptional experience.
